💔 A Night Out That Ended In Tragedy

What was supposed to be a simple night out turned into a devastating tragedy for 26-year-old Jarrell Pryor, a hardworking single dad from Indianapolis.

On a Saturday night in January, Jarrell had just wrapped up his warehouse shift and was excited to meet Alexis Hawkins, a young woman he’d recently connected with on Instagram.

But what he didn’t know was that Hawkins had other plans.

Less than two hours after they met up, Jarrell was found shot multiple times outside his car near 49th and Primrose, just north of the Indiana State Fairgrounds.

He died shortly after at the hospital.

đŸ“± The Setup: What Police Discovered

According to investigators, Hawkins, 19, was allegedly texting her real boyfriend—18-year-old Brian Winston Jr.—throughout the night, planning a robbery under the guise of a date.

Surveillance, text messages, and witness statements pointed to a disturbing scheme that ended Jarrell’s life far too soon.

Though Hawkins initially denied involvement, police say she eventually admitted to being at the scene but denied participating in the violence.

When detectives confronted her with messages like “I need money” and plans to “make a play real fast,” she lawyered up.

Both Hawkins and Winston are now charged with murder and attempted robbery.

They remain in custody without bond.

Alexis-Hawkins-Brian-Johnston-Jr
Credit: Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department

đŸ‘¶ A Father Taken Too Soon

Jarrell Pryor’s greatest joy in life was his 3-year-old daughter, Honey.

Described as loving, funny, and full of potential, Pryor was committed to raising his daughter—even after separating from her mother.

His family says he never missed a chance to brag about her or buy her tiny Jordans to match his.

“He always found a way to bring her up in conversation,” said his friend Anijah Randle.

Now, Honey lives with her mother, Ja’halha Feemster, and her family—who are doing their best to keep Jarrell’s memory alive.

“She looks for him and says, ‘Da-Da,’” says her great-grandmother, Patricia Bradshaw. “It tears us up every time.”

Jarrell Pryor, Indianapolis father and shooting victim, pictured smiling with daughter Honey
Jarrell and daughter Honey

🕊 Remembering Jarrell Pryor

Jarrell was more than a victim—he was a performer, a gamer, an entrepreneur at heart, and a man determined to grow.

From selling candy in grade school to dreaming of pro-gaming success, he was a go-getter.

He even once did a full Michael Jackson tribute at school, just for fun.

“He had so many plans,” said his mother, Tamekia Wiley. “He was always trying to better himself.”

⚖ Seeking Justice, Living With Pain

While the arrests brought some relief, Jarrell’s family says nothing can heal the pain of losing him.

“They took everything from us,” said his stepdad, Travis Wiley. “And they got nothing out of it.”

Even if the suspects are convicted, the grief remains. “No justice will ever cure my broken heart,” Tamekia shared. “It won’t bring my baby back.”

As the legal case unfolds, Jarrell’s family is focused on keeping his memory alive—especially for Honey.

“I pray for her to have a supernatural memory so she can remember him,” said her grandmother, N’yalha Feemster.

“Because we all deserved Jarrell. We absolutely did.”

Lock In With Ice Cream Convos